I also have the Luna Mono Gordo, which are no longer made. These are thicker and probably better if you are hiking, or just want one sandal.
I recently tried Vibrams for the first time and the (at times painful) connection to the ground was a revelation.
I would go with the Leadville Pacer Trail for off road and trail.
I would go with the Venado for street and around town use.
Both would work for trip to a weird place like Portland or San Francisco. Not as okay for a place like New York or Chicago.